In Linden, California, Bracksieck and Judge attended Linden High School. Before graduation in 2010, Judge participated in three sports there: baseball, basketball, and football.

Both Bracksieck and Judge attended Fresno State University in California following high school.

Although Bracksieck and Judge don’t interact on social media much, in November 2014, Bracksieck made an appearance on Judge’s Instagram account. The couple was shown in the picture collage running a 5K on Thanksgiving Day alongside Judge’s parents.

With the exception of the 2014 post, Bracksieck is hardly ever seen on Judge’s social media accounts. When the two travelled to Los Angeles in July 2022 for the MLB All-Star Break, it is the only other occasion she has been featured on his Instagram profile.

On Febuary 17, 2024, Judge and Bracksieck tied the knot in a secret ceremony on Maui, Hawaii, as reported by the Daily Mail. Images that the newspaper was able to procure showed the pair saying their vows at the Montage Kapalua Bay Resort beneath a striking arch made of flowers and foliage. Judge wore a traditional black tuxedo, while Bracksieck wore a form-fitting gown with an illusion neckline, a detailed back, and a lengthy veil.

Never having made an official announcement about their engagement, the pair married in front of a small group of people, including a few of Judge’s New York Yankees teammates. Twitter users shared pictures of Gleyber Torres, Luis Cessa, and Gary Sanchez of the Yankees attending the wedding in Hawaii.