In 2022, the Pittsburgh Pirates suffered yet another dismal season, concluding in last place in the NL Central with a 62-100 record. It was their fourth losing season in a row. The Pirates are expecting to compete for a Wild Card place in 2023 after missing the postseason since 2015. However, some of their young talent is still growing. This raises the question: this offseason, should the Pirates think about trading closer David Bednar?

Over the last two seasons, Bednar has become one of baseball’s best relief relievers. He threw 60.2 innings in 2022, with 35 saves, and 87 strikeouts, all while maintaining a 2.70 ERA. In his maiden All-Star squad, the 27-year-old was selected. He had a 2.00 ERA for the season in 2023 and was also selected for the all-star game. and will remain in team hands until 2026. In 2023, Bednar was an uncommon bright spot on a team that had few reliable players.

But the Pittsburgh Pirates could be better served keeping Bednar if they hope to compete for a postseason position the following year. As a shutout closer who shortens games and steadies the bullpen, he adds enormous value. Having a great closer might result in several extra victories for the Pirates, who are predicted to play in more close, low-scoring games as a peripheral contender.

The Pittsburgh Pirates might still get a nice return for Bednar in a trade this winter, according to the counterargument. Even though the farm system is now better, there is still a need for young starting pitchers. Relocating Bednar might make it easier to sign a pitching prospect who is almost ready for the Major Leagues.

In the end, it could be wiser for the Pirates to hold onto Bednar for the upcoming year and reassess at the 2023 trade deadline. Even if they are obviously out of the running, he might still make a good trade chip. However, he adds greater worth to the team roster if they are contending for a postseason spot.